Indian or Western toilet with knee or hip pain: squatting, getting up safely and aids for elders

For many older Indians, the toilet is the hardest part of the day. Squatting on an Indian toilet needs the knees and hips to bend fully and then push the whole body back up, and that is exactly what painful knees, weak thighs or a new joint replacement cannot do well. A fall in the bathroom is also one of the most common ways elders get hurt. The fix is often simple and inexpensive, and it can be arranged from another city or country.

Written by Dr. V. B. Rajendra Prasad, MPT, licensed in the US and UK. 20 years of clinical experience.Reviewed by Dr. Rajendra on 12 November 2026. Last updated 12 November 2026. How we write and check our pages

Why squatting is hard on painful knees and hips

A full squat bends the knee further than almost any other daily activity, and the kneecap and the cartilage behind it take high pressure at the bottom. For a healthy, strong knee that is fine. For a knee with arthritis, a torn meniscus or swelling, it is often the most painful position of the day.

Getting up is the harder half. The thigh and hip muscles have to lift the full body weight from the lowest position, often on a wet floor, while holding a mug or a tap. Weak thigh muscles are common in older adults, especially after an illness or a hospital stay, and this is when people wobble, grab the nearest thing, and fall.

Squatting does not damage a healthy knee, and many people who have squatted all their lives keep doing it comfortably. The question is not whether the Indian toilet is "bad", but whether this particular person can get down and up safely, every time, including at night.

Signs it is time to change the toilet

Needing to hold the wall, door or tap to get up. Taking several attempts to rise, or rising with a lurch. Pain in the knee or hip that is worst in the toilet. Avoiding drinking water so as to use the toilet less. Any fall or near fall in the bathroom.

After a knee replacement, most people do not regain enough bend to squat fully, and many surgeons advise against it. After a hip replacement, especially in the first few weeks, deep bending of the hip is often restricted. Ask your surgeon what is allowed for your operation, and arrange a raised Western seat before discharge rather than after.

Options, from cheapest to most permanent

A commode chair or commode stool that sits over the Indian toilet. These are widely sold by medical shops and online, and many fold away. It turns the squat into sitting, with armrests to push up from. Choose one with rubber feet that stand firmly on the floor, and check the height suits the person.

A raised toilet seat on an existing Western toilet. A seat that adds a few inches of height makes standing up much easier for people with knee arthritis or after hip or knee surgery. Some come with armrests. The NHS lists a raised toilet seat among the most useful aids after a hip replacement.

A bedside commode for the night. If an elder gets up two or three times a night, a commode chair next to the bed removes the walk to a wet bathroom in the dark, which is when many falls happen.

Converting to a Western toilet. If one bathroom can be changed, ask the plumber for a seat height that suits the person, not just the standard model, and fit grab bars at the same time.

Grab bars and a safer bathroom

Fit a proper grab bar, screwed into the wall, beside the toilet. A towel rod, tap or plastic bucket will not hold body weight and gives way just as someone leans on it. A vertical or angled bar at the side is usually easiest to push and pull from.

Use a rubber-backed non-slip mat, keep the floor as dry as you can, and keep the mug, health faucet and soap within reach so no one has to twist or bend sideways. Leave a night light on in the bathroom and along the way to it.

If the bathroom door opens inwards and someone falls against it, it is hard to get in. Avoid locking the door, or change the latch so it can be opened from outside.

How to sit down and get up safely

Walk until the backs of the legs touch the seat. Reach back for the armrests or grab bar with both hands, then lower slowly. Do not drop onto the seat.

To get up, shuffle forward to the front of the seat, place the feet slightly apart and a little behind the knees, lean forward so the nose comes over the toes, and push through the hands and the legs together. Pause standing for a few seconds before walking, especially at night, as blood pressure can drop on standing.

The same movement, practised from a chair, is the best exercise for toilet safety. Strong thighs make every toilet easier.

Exercises that help, with pictures

Arranging this for a parent from another city or abroad

You can order a commode chair, raised seat and grab bars online and have them delivered and fitted by a local carpenter or plumber. A video call during the fitting lets you check the bar height and position.

A physiotherapist can watch your parent sit down and get up on a video call, suggest the right height and aids, and set a short strengthening programme that makes it safer over a few weeks.

When to see a doctor

See a doctor after any fall with pain, a head injury, or difficulty standing afterwards. Also see one if knee or hip pain comes with swelling, redness and fever, or if a leg suddenly gives way, or if needing the toilet many times at night is new.

Sources

This page draws on clinical guidelines and patient information from these organisations, alongside our own clinical experience. Our editorial policy

Frequently asked questions

Is an Indian toilet bad for knee arthritis?
Not for everyone. Squatting does not damage a healthy knee, but with arthritis it is often painful, and getting up from a full squat needs strong thighs. If it hurts, or getting up needs support from a wall or tap, a commode chair or raised Western seat is safer.
Can I use an Indian toilet after knee replacement?
Most people do not get enough bend after a knee replacement to squat fully, and many surgeons advise against it. Use a Western toilet with a raised seat or a commode chair over the Indian toilet, and ask your surgeon about your own knee.
What is the best toilet aid for an elderly parent?
It depends on the toilet and the person. A commode chair over an Indian toilet, or a raised seat with armrests on a Western toilet, plus a grab bar fixed to the wall, solves the problem for most families. A bedside commode helps if they get up often at night.
Can squatting exercises help me use the Indian toilet again?
Sometimes. If the knees are not badly damaged, strengthening the thighs and hips and practising partial squats with support can restore the ability over weeks. A physiotherapist can judge whether it is a realistic goal for you and set the right exercises.
Dr. Rajendra

Written by Dr. V. B. Rajendra Prasad, MPT. Licensed to practice in the US (NY state) and UK (HCPC).
20 years of clinical experience. About Dr. Rajendra

Need personalized guidance?

Talk to a Nuprana physiotherapist online from anywhere in India.

Talk to Us on WhatsApp