TENS machines, massage guns, heating pads and knee caps: which are worth buying?

Online shops are full of devices promising pain relief, from TENS machines and massage guns to heating pads, knee caps and posture belts. Some are useful for comfort; none of them fixes the reason pain keeps coming back. Here is an honest look at what each one does, so you can decide what is worth your money.

Written by Dr. V. B. Rajendra Prasad, MPT, licensed in the US and UK. 20 years of clinical experience.Reviewed by Dr. Rajendra on 22 November 2026. Last updated 22 November 2026. How we write and check our pages

TENS machines

A TENS machine sends a mild electrical current through pads on the skin, which you feel as tingling. It works by dulling pain signals while it is on. A large review of 381 studies found that pain was lower during and immediately after TENS than with a fake device, and that side effects, usually mild skin irritation, were uncommon.

The relief usually fades soon after it is switched off, and it does not change the cause. The UK's NICE guideline advises against TENS for low back pain, because it does not improve how people recover. It can still be reasonable for short-term relief to help you move, for example before a walk.

Do not use TENS if you have a pacemaker or other implanted electrical device, epilepsy, or a heart condition without checking with your doctor, and do not use it on the front of the neck, over the eyes, on broken skin, or on the abdomen or back in pregnancy unless a professional advises it.

Massage guns

A massage gun is a handheld device that taps rapidly on the muscle. Reviews of the research found short-term improvements in muscle flexibility and stiffness, mostly in healthy, active people after exercise. Effects on strength and performance were mixed, and there is little research on back, neck or joint pain conditions.

Used gently on large muscles such as the thighs, calves and buttocks, it can feel good after exercise or a long day. Keep it off the spine, neck, joints, bony areas, bruises, varicose veins and areas that are numb. Do not use one if you take blood thinners, have osteoporosis, or have had a recent injury or blood clot, without asking a professional.

Heating pads and hot water bags

Heat is one of the cheapest and safest ways to ease stiffness and muscle spasm, and research supports it for short-term relief of recent back pain. A rubber hot water bag works as well as an electric pad for most people.

If you buy an electric pad, choose one with a temperature setting and an automatic switch-off, use it on low, keep a cloth between it and the skin, and never fall asleep on it. People with diabetes or reduced feeling in the skin should be especially careful, as they may not notice a burn.

Knee caps, back belts and neck collars

A soft knee cap gives warmth and a feeling of support, and some people with knee arthritis feel more confident walking with one. NICE advises against routinely using braces, supports or insoles for osteoarthritis unless the joint is unstable or a specialist recommends one for how the joint is loading.

Worn all day for months, supports can let the muscles around a joint get weaker, which can make pain worse over time. Back belts and neck collars have the same problem; our guide on them explains when they help and when they hold you back.

If you use a support, wear it for the activities that are hardest, such as a long walk or travel, and keep strengthening the muscles around the joint.

Exercises that help, with pictures

What to spend on instead

For most back, neck and knee pain, the most useful things to buy are cheap: a hot water bag, a resistance band, and comfortable walking shoes. A good exercise plan, done regularly, will usually do more than any device.

If you are unsure what your pain needs, a session with a physiotherapist costs about the same as many of these devices and can tell you what is causing it, which exercises to do, and whether any device is worth using alongside them.

Frequently asked questions

Is a TENS machine good for back pain?
It can reduce pain while it is on and for a short time after, and it is safe for most people. It does not help back pain recover, which is why UK guidelines advise against it as a treatment. Use it, if at all, to make walking and exercise more comfortable.
Can a massage gun fix muscle knots or back pain?
It can loosen tight muscles for a short while, and research shows short-term flexibility gains after exercise. There is little evidence it treats back pain. Keep it off the spine and joints, and use exercise to deal with the cause.
Should I wear a knee cap for knee pain?
A soft knee cap can give warmth and confidence for long walks, but wearing one all day can let the thigh muscles weaken. UK guidelines advise against routine braces for knee arthritis unless the knee is unstable. Strengthening the thigh muscles helps more.
Is an electric heating pad better than a hot water bag?
Not for relief. Both give the same kind of heat. An electric pad is convenient, but choose one with a temperature control and automatic switch-off, use it on low, and never sleep on it.
Dr. Rajendra

Written by Dr. V. B. Rajendra Prasad, MPT. Licensed to practice in the US (NY state) and UK (HCPC).
20 years of clinical experience. About Dr. Rajendra

Need personalized guidance?

Talk to a Nuprana physiotherapist online from anywhere in India.

Talk to Us on WhatsApp