Walker, stick or wheelchair? Choosing a walking aid for a parent

The right walking aid can give an older person back their confidence. The wrong one, or the right one set at the wrong height, can make falls more likely. Here is how the main options compare, how to set them up and when to ask a physiotherapist.

Written by Dr. V. B. Rajendra Prasad, MPT, licensed in the US and UK. 20 years of clinical experience.

Walking stick

A single walking stick suits someone who is mostly steady but has pain or mild weakness on one side, or who wants a little extra security outdoors. It gives light support and does little for poor balance.

Hold it in the hand opposite the painful or weaker leg, and move it forward at the same time as that leg.

Quad stick

A stick with four small feet stands on its own and is more stable than a single stick. It is often used after a stroke. It is slower and works best on flat floors, because all four feet need to touch the ground.

Walker

A walker without wheels gives the most support for walking. It suits people after hip or knee surgery, those with significant weakness and those with poor balance. It is lifted and placed forward with each step, so it is slow and needs some arm strength.

A walker with two front wheels does not need lifting and gives a smoother walking pattern, while still being stable.

Rollator

A rollator has four wheels, hand brakes and usually a seat. It suits people who walk reasonably well but tire quickly and need to rest, especially outdoors. It rolls easily, so it is not right for someone who leans heavily on it or has poor balance, unless they use the brakes reliably.

Wheelchair

A wheelchair is for distances your parent cannot walk safely, such as hospital visits, temples or travel, or for people who cannot walk. Using one for longer outings can help someone stay active, because it saves their energy for walking at home. The risk is using it for everything, which leads to further weakness.

Setting the right height

With your parent standing straight and arms relaxed by their sides, the handle of a stick or walker should be level with the crease of the wrist. When they hold it, the elbow should bend slightly. Too high and the shoulders hunch. Too low and they stoop forward, which shifts their weight forward and raises the risk of a fall.

Check the rubber tips regularly and replace them when they wear smooth.

Common mistakes

Using a stick borrowed from a relative at the wrong height. Pushing a walker too far ahead and leaning into it. Carrying the stick instead of using it. Using a walker on stairs, which it is not designed for. Leaving the aid behind at night on the way to the bathroom.

Frequently asked questions

Which hand should hold the walking stick?
Usually the hand opposite the weaker or painful leg. For a painful right knee, hold the stick in the left hand. The stick and the painful leg then move forward and share the load together.
My father refuses to use a walker because it makes him feel old. What can I do?
This is very common. It can help to present it as a tool for getting out more rather than a sign of decline, and to agree on where it is needed, for example outdoors or at night. A physiotherapist can also work on his strength and balance with the goal of moving to a simpler aid.
Can a physiotherapist help choose the right aid by video?
Yes. Watching your parent walk on video, with and without support, is usually enough to recommend the right aid, set its height and teach them how to use it.
Dr. Rajendra

Written by Dr. V. B. Rajendra Prasad, MPT. Licensed to practice in the US (NY state) and UK (HCPC).
20 years of clinical experience. About Dr. Rajendra

Need personalized guidance?

Talk to a Nuprana physiotherapist online from anywhere in India.

Talk to Us on WhatsApp